Where do you get your ideas for the books you write? That’s a question every author gets and one that often frustrates them. Many don’t know where they got the idea for a particularly story? Do we remember three years later, when we finish the fourth draft, where the germ of the original idea came from? And when we compare the fourth draft to the first, how can tell when the final idea took root out of the mess that was the first draft?
A story idea is not a static thing that lights up like a bulb above your head. It’s a seed that falls to the ground and dies and comes popping out of the soil of the imagination as a fresh shoot, and keeps on growing and changing and maturing, until you have a full-grown oak tree that looks nothing like the little acorn you started with. When does the acorn become a tree? When does AN idea become THE IDEA for that particular story?
And if the one asking the question is asking something more generic, such as, “Where do you get ideas for any story, not for one particular story?” that’s no easier to answer, really.
I brainstorm, but I admit, I’m not one of those writers who has ideas bulging out her brain and who can’t find enough time to write them all. Ideas are hard for me to come by. I have to shake the trees a long time to get even one acorn to fall.
I have given two speeches at the new Toastmasters club I joined last month and I’m hard-pressed to come up with an idea for a third. Blog posts come no more easily. I stare at the screen and struggle to find something to write about. Same with short stories. I’d like to enter several short story contests and submit to a few children’s magazines, but I can’t come up with ideas.
Rebecca LuElla Miller tells us that story ideas are everywhere. And I agree with that. She goes on to say there is a bit of a trick in discovering which ideas will be interesting to write about.
And that, I think, is what children want to know when they ask authors during school visits, “Where do you get your ideas?” I think they want to know how to bring their passions to the page. Of course there are ideas everywhere, but they don’t all make a good story idea. They won’t all make interesting speeches.
What we need is passion.
On one wall in my living room there is a picture of elephants running, on another wall the Château de Chillon. My mother sits in one chair watching TV, my sister lies on the loveseat with a book. I’m on the couch with earphones in, listening to Apocalyptica and blogging. There are bookshelves bulging with clutter, lamps, a fan, several computers, a tea-cup, and a floor that needs to be vacuumed. Hmm. None of these inspire me to write a story about them.
The Château de Chillon has some promise. I was there when I was six. I remember a toilet there, it looked like an outhouse seat, but the hole was a chute that went all the way down to the lake, and I remember seeing Lord Byron’s signature carved into the post in the dungeon. And I actually put some of those memories into a novel I’ve written. But does the castle give me an idea for a story?
It gave Lord Byron an idea.
What we need is a character. We need a character who wants something. A character who can’t have what he wants. A prisoner who couldn’t get free, a prisoner who lost all of nature and all his family, found his way into Lord Byron’s mind and burst out in a poem, after Byron looked at the dungeon at the château.
Stories are about people. Maybe the people in the stories are robots or toasters or bunny rabbits, but they are people still. All stories are about people.
I guess all I can say for sure about ideas right now: They have to be about people in some kind of trouble.
Where do you get your ideas?


My stories always start with characters. The one I’m working on now has characters I thought up 20 years ago. Their story has completely changed, but they are the same characters.
I remember one day I watched parents drop their small children off at ballet class at a local church. One of them was a dad dropping off two little girls. When I got home, I wrote a synopsis for a novel about a divorced cop with 2 little girls. He’d lost everything in the divorce and just moved to Atlanta. His wife moved to Seattle. She didn’t want the kids.
So I guess I just see people in different situations and get story ideas. I once saw a tv commercial in which a couple were arguing on a runway in front of a private jet. I concocted a very long scene from that commercial. I can go on and on, but I think you get where I’m coming from. I get my fiction ideas by creating characters first and then a story.
With non fiction, I’m so opinionated that I can probably just rant about something I feel passionate about! :-)
Suzan´s last [type] ..New Year, New Focus
Suzan these are great ideas. I hear writers talk like this all the time and I just can’t do it. I’ve people-watched at airports and tried to come up with stories and I just can’t do it. These all sound like great ideas to me, though. And I love the characters in your present story and I love the story too. So the old characters and new story are working really well together.
So write about the people who live where the cluttered bookcases are … or the ones who might … or the pastor who comes to visit the people or the neighbors next door or the little girl who dreams of living somewhere else or the daughter who wishes to move in and can’t or … SO MANY STORIES!!!
Rebecca LuElla Miller´s last [type] ..Fantasy Friday – What’s Better Than Tolkien?
OH, yeah. Why didn’t I think of all those story ideas? So EASY.
The thing is that it is work to come up with story ideas because we have to come up with conflict. It’s work. That’s my point. The ideas don’t bulge out of my brain like many writers say happens to them. I have to brainstorm. So finding ideas can be learned and taught. But it is a skill. It is work. It may come naturally for you, but it never comes naturally for me. You might say when it comes to ideas, I’m a little….
ha ha I’ve always wanted to use that smiley.
Sorry. I’m so easily amused.
I really like Apocalyptica. My son introduced me to them a few years ago because he likes rock and I like classical, and he was trying to help me understand the musicality behind his music. I got it!
In a way, that group is a perfect motif for exploring the “What if’s” of story ideas. What if you took the hardest rock tunes and played them on classical cellos? What if the things that go missing in our homes were actually taken by little Borrowers? What if you woke up in another time and place? What if…
Ah yes. What if…. That is a great way to come up with story ideas.
And, yes, some of Apocalyptica’s stuff is so good. I am driven to want to create things of beauty when I listen to some of their music.
OK….I have to admit it that I am one of those obnoxious people who walks around bulging and bursting with ideas. But it usually feels like more of a curse than a blessing. It makes it hard to be really present, in the moment. It makes it REALLY hard to stick to one project all the way to first draft novel. It is part of the reason I talk to myself incessantly, expecially in the car…one friend saw me doing this and told me I took quite insane (and yes, I answer myself). Due to my poor writing habits, most of my lovely ideas die unborn. Usually, if I’m really taken with an idea, I’ll sit down with good old pencil and paper as write stream-of-conciousness about it. Then I put it away for at least a day. Usually much longer. If I’m drawn back to it, if I want to write more about it, then I know it’s going to be one of my heartier ideas that might actually make it to the keyboard. Sally, I try not to pass out advice because….well, who am I to advise anyone? But seriously, there’s some cool writer’s idea books out there with evocative images. I love looking at beautiful/creepy/evocative photos to see if they light some spark of an idea. Joshilyn Jackson’s new book is based on a single gorgous photograph by Cig Harvey (and the photo ended up as the cover of her book). And even if you don’t get any ideas, looking at beautiful images feeds the soul, yes?
Trisha Slay´s last [type] ..Is Self-Publishing the New Submission Process?
I also talk to myself. All the time. Even in the store. I sometimes catch people looking at me oddly and I realize I’ve been talking to myself, telling myself what I have to buy. I don’t think I’m crazy, though. I just think I need to write things down. And I’ve always talked to myself when I’m in my fantasy world, thinking up stories.
Yes, looking at beautiful images feeds the soul. And yet, I’ve never been able to come up with a story idea from looking at pictures. When my teachers used to do that in school, I would sit for a half hour writing nothing. I don’t know where I get ideas, but I know I don’t get them people-watching or picture-viewing.
Hmmm I suck as a writer.
But I know I get ideas from nature (being out in it not looking at it in a picture) and from reading great books. I’m not sure where else.